← The Wire·Crypto·

CryptoQuant says Michael Saylor's Strategy should halt its bitcoin buying

CryptoQuant warns that Strategy's preferred share coverage has collapsed from seven years to just 14 months as BTC purchases near cycle tops have generated a $10.6 billion paper loss. The thinning liquidity cushion raises solvency questions around MSTR's leveraged bitcoin accumulation model if BTC prices remain suppressed.

The story

CryptoQuant, a leading on-chain analytics firm, published a note arguing that Michael Saylor's Strategy (MSTR) should pause its bitcoin buying. The firm highlights that the cash buffer backing Strategy's STRK/STRC preferred shares has eroded dramatically — from roughly seven years of coverage down to just 14 months — a direct consequence of continued BTC purchases near what CryptoQuant characterizes as cycle tops.

The company's financials underscore the tension: MSTR reported FY revenue of $477.2M (+3% YoY) with a 68.7% gross margin, but net margins stand at a staggering -806.3% and diluted EPS is -$15.23, reflecting the enormous mark-to-market swings tied to its bitcoin treasury. The $10.6 billion paper loss figure captures the gap between average acquisition cost and current BTC prices.

The second-order risk is a potential liquidity crunch at the preferred share level. If BTC prices stay range-bound or fall further, Strategy's capacity to service preferred dividends and maintain the NAV premium that justifies its equity valuation could come under pressure — forcing dilutive equity raises or, in a tail scenario, asset sales.

The bull case remains that Bitcoin recovers sharply, paper losses reverse, and Strategy's first-mover advantage in corporate BTC treasury management is repriced higher. The bear case is that the shrinking coverage ratio is a concrete, measurable deterioration that the market has not yet fully priced into MSTR's still-elevated premium to net asset value. What to watch: BTC price relative to Strategy's average cost basis (~$67-68K), any new ATM equity raises, and preferred share coverage disclosures in the next 10-Q.

Our read · Wed, Jun 24

MSTR's preferred share coverage has collapsed to 14 months — the question is whether the market has priced in the liquidity deterioration or whether the NAV premium still masks the risk.

Why. MSTR trades at a significant premium to its BTC net asset value despite a -806% net margin, -$15.23 EPS, and now a CryptoQuant-documented collapse in preferred share coverage from 7 years to 14 months. The paper loss of $10.6B signals purchases near cycle tops, and if BTC remains range-bound, the justification for the NAV premium erodes while dilutive ATM raises remain a constant overhang. The preferred coverage ratio is a concrete, quantifiable deterioration that is less visible in headline BTC price trackers and may not yet be fully reflected in MSTR equity.

Both cases

The case it holdsIf Bitcoin reclaims and holds above Strategy's average acquisition cost (~$67-68K), the $10.6B paper loss evaporates, coverage ratios recover, and MSTR's institutional first-mover premium in corporate BTC treasury could command a significant NAV multiple again.
The case it breaksWith preferred share coverage compressed to just 14 months and diluted EPS at -$15.23, any prolonged BTC sideways/downside move structurally challenges MSTR's ability to sustain preferred dividends and justify its current NAV premium without further dilutive equity issuance.

What could change this view: A sharp BTC rally above MSTR's ~$67-68K average cost basis would erase the paper loss, re-inflate NAV, and likely trigger a short squeeze given MSTR's historically high short interest and retail momentum following.

Strategy stock page →
Your side is graded privately against closes after 10 trading days. Research, not advice.

Who reported it · 1

Keep reading

More on MSTR

Strategy files 8-K for October 12 capital-markets updatesStrategy uses $139.3 million to repurchase STRC preferred stockStrategy raises $2 billion through MSTR sales and creates new USD Cash poolBitcoin falls below $64k as Hormuz hopes fade, Strategy sells more coinsMSTR hits 52-week low as bitcoin drops to $62,000 amid global equity rout

Latest on the Wire

Australia’s jobless rate hits 5-year high, markets ramp up rate-cut bets for 2027Trump meets Putin and Xi separately ahead of historic three-way talksHyperscale Data warns of $74.8 million gap for Michigan AI projectAlibaba aided China military-linked lab with AI computing technologyMeta pauses plan to give Zuckerberg new shares without losing controlContinue on the Wire →

Top this week

Nvidia allies lobby board to bring back Jensen Huang as CEONvidia chair rules out Huang return as CEO after 75% sales outlookNvidia interim CEO Colette Kress faces first earnings test after HuangNvidia CEO Jensen Huang reportedly resigns as US-China tensions riseNvidia CFO Colette Kress to serve as interim CEO after Jensen Huang
The Wire at 7 AM ET, free. Top stories with a bull and a bear case on each, every morning. No account needed.

About this report

Reported by CoinDesk, . Who answers for this

The only report in this record. Closes are licensed end-of-day data from Databento; the move after a story is its first close against the close before it. How this is decided →

Kept as written · your side, if you take one, is graded privately against licensed closes after 10 trading days · nothing here is advice · How the Wire is made →