Judge lets DRAM price-fixing suit against Samsung, SK Hynix, Micron proceed
A federal judge in San Jose has refused to dismiss a price-fixing suit accusing Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron of running a DRAM cartel, clearing the way for discovery. The ruling means the three memory makers' internal pricing and capacity communications can now be pulled into the case, just as soaring memory prices ripple through PCs, phones and producer prices.
STOCK PHOTO · JOHANNES PLENIOThe story
A federal judge in San Jose has declined to throw out the antitrust suit alleging that Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron coordinated DRAM pricing, according to ZeroHedge's account of the ruling at the weekend. The decision lets the case proceed into discovery, the phase in which plaintiffs can demand internal documents, emails and communications from the three defendants.
The suit lands after a year in which memory prices have been a recurring macro story. ZeroHedge has traced the effect through PC shipments in January, producer prices in June, Apple's price list shortly after, and by July the Fed itself, with Goldman cited as having flagged the issue. The same three producers dominate global DRAM supply, which is why the pricing-power allegation carries weight.
The companies touched are the three defendants directly: Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron, whose DRAM margins depend on the pricing behaviour now under scrutiny. Apple and PC makers sit on the other side as large memory buyers whose component costs have risen, and Goldman is named as a source of commentary on the price pass-through.
A denied motion to dismiss is a procedural step, not a finding of liability. The defendants can still contest the allegations, and earlier DRAM price-fixing litigation shows such cases can run for years. Discovery may produce evidence of coordination, or it may not.
Watch for any scheduling order setting discovery deadlines, defendant filings or appeals, and the memory makers' next earnings commentary on pricing and supply discipline.
Our read · Sun, Nov 15
A San Jose federal judge refused to dismiss the DRAM cartel suit against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron, sending it into discovery.
Why. Discovery is the mechanism that matters: it forces the three producers to hand over pricing and capacity communications that a motion to dismiss kept sealed. Any evidence of coordination would reframe the memory-price run as a legal and regulatory issue, not just a cycle. Buyers like Apple gain leverage only if the case produces damaging documents, which is years away.
Both cases
What could change this view: The suit can still fail on the evidence, settle cheaply, or drag on for years with no change to pricing behaviour.
Who reported it · 1
Keep reading
More on AAPL
Apple revenue reaches $114.5 billion as China sales miss estimatesApple’s first Ternus earnings report arrives amid memory-cost pressureApple’s $2,000 foldable Duo slips to 2027 after launch selloutJudge likely to bar OpenAI from using Apple trade secretsQualcomm and Apple extend chip licensing agreementLatest on the Wire
Trump threatens overseas AI data-centre ban for US firmsBitcoin drops below $59,000 as cash rush revives summer-low testGreer says US chip curbs will close China export-control loopholesBlackRock bitcoin ETF posts $541.1 million outflow as tech sell-off spreadsPoland says Russian missiles and drone crashed during Ukraine assaultContinue on the Wire →Latest on the Wire
Poland says Russian missiles and drone crashed during Ukraine assaultAnthropic debut fails to halt technology-led slide in US stocksBeijing plans to bar young red-chip firms from overseas listingsGerman producer prices jump 8.1% in October as industrial inflation acceleratesContinue on the Wire →Top this week
Nvidia allies lobby board to bring back Jensen Huang as CEONvidia chair rules out Huang return as CEO after 75% sales outlookAnthropic Said to Guide IPO Pricing Above Market RangeNvidia interim CEO Colette Kress faces first earnings test after HuangAnthropic IPO could become the largest in US history on ThursdayAbout this report
Reported by ZeroHedge as "Hawks Flying In Formation": Judge Refuses To Toss DRAM Cartel Suit Against Samsung, SK Hynix And Micron, Opening Door To Discovery
, . Who answers for this
The only report in this record. Closes are licensed end-of-day data from Databento; the move after a story is its first close against the close before it. How this is decided →
Kept as written · your side, if you take one, is graded privately against licensed closes after 10 trading days · nothing here is advice · How the Wire is made →